AP16/1-2/2020

Ballyness Bay, Co Donegal

 

Appeal Ref Appellant Site Ref Subject matter of appeal Applicant Licence Type Determination Date Minister's Decision Status of Appeal Oral Hearing Requested
AP16/2/2020 Save Ballyness Bay T12/516A Appeal against the decision by the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine to grant an Aquaculture Licence to Joseph Coll to cultivate Pacific Oysters using bags and trestles on the inter‐tidal foreshore on site ref T12/516A in Ballyness Bay, Co. Donegal Joseph Coll New License Pacific Oysters using bags & Trestles 22 May 2024 Grant Stage 5: Determination Made Yes
AP16/1/2020 Joe Friel Yes

 

Notice of Appeal

Date Appeal Ref View Document
02 January 2020 AP16/2/2020 AP16/2/2020 - Redacted Appeal (pdf 29,595Kb) 
02 January 2020 AP16/1/2020 AP16/1/2020 - Redacted Appeal (pdf 7,209Kb) 

 

Administration of Appeal

Date Document Type View Document
09 January 2020 Acknowledgement of Appeal AP16/1-2/2020 - Acknowledgement of Appeal (pdf 1,605Kb) 
04 February 2020 Notification of Appeal AP16/1-2/2020 - Notification of Appeals (pdf 2,523Kb) 
Time Extension Letters
Received 02 January 2020 01 May 2020 (Original) N/A
24 March 2020 31 December 2020 AP16/1-2/2020 - 2020 March Time Extensions (pdf 1,304Kb) 
10 November 2020 30 June 2021 AP16/1-2/2020 - 2020 November Time Extensions (pdf 1,051Kb) 
 09 June 2021 31 December 2021 AP16/1-2/2020 - 2021 June Time Extensions (pdf 695Kb) 
29 November 2021 30 June 2022 AP16/1-2/2020 - 2021 November Time Extensions (pdf 216Kb) 
 16 May 2022 31 December 2022 AP16/1-2/2020 - 2022 May Time Extensions (pdf 367Kb) 
 20 December 2022 30 September 2023 AP16/1-2/2020 - 2022 December Time Extensions (pdf 219Kb) 
10 August 2023 30 April 2024

AP16/1-2/2020 - 2023 August Time Extensions (pdf 4,167Kb) 

AP3-16/2020 - Time Extension & Cover Note to Observers (pdf 2,142Kb) 

17 April 2024 31 May 2024

AP16/1-2/2020 - 2024 April Time Extensions (pdf 260Kb) 

AP3-16/2020 - 2024 April Time Extensions (Observers) (pdf 141Kb) 

Consolidation Letters & Information Notes
29 November 2020 Consolidation of Appeals AP3-16/2020 - Consolidation of Appeals (pdf 887Kb) 
06 December 2023 Information Letter AP3-16/2020 - Information Letter to All Parties (pdf 1,702Kb) 

 

DAFM File

Date of Request Date of Receipt View Document
09 January 2020 23 January 2020 AP16/1-2/2020 - Consolidated DAFM File (pdf 8,672Kb) 
09 January 2020 23 January 2020 Appropriate Assessment Ballyness Bay Report (pdf 2,298Kb) 
09 January 2020 23 January 2020 Ballyness Bay Final AA Conclusion Statement (pdf 1,038Kb) 

 

Observations - Sections 44 (Party) & 45 (Non-Party)

Date of Receipt  From View Document
11 March 2020 Donegal County Council AP3-16/2020 - Observations from Donegal C.C (pdf 309Kb) 
12 March 2020 An Taisce AP3-16/2020 - Observations from An Taisce (pdf 172Kb) 
12 March 2020 Save Ballyness Bay AP3-16/2020 - Observations from Madden & Finucane Solicitors (pdf 8,500Kb) 
21 February 2020 Edward & Paul O’Brien AP16/1-2/2020 - Observations from Licensee (pdf 3,582Kb) 

 

Information Requests

Date Recipient View Request View Submission
24 March 2023 Marine Institute AP3-16-2020 - S47 Request to Marine Institute (pdf 916Kb)  AP3-16/2020 - S47 Reply from Marine Institute (pdf 54Kb) 
01 August 2023 Marine Institute AP3-16/2020 - S47 Follow up letter to MI (pdf 42Kb)   
01 August 2023 NPWS AP3-16/2020 - S46 Request to NPWS (pdf 1,596Kb) 

AP3-16/2020 - NPWS Response to S46 (pdf 70Kb) 

AP3-16/2020 - ALAB response to NPWS S46 (pdf 155Kb) 

04 August 2023 Applicant AP16/1-2/2020 - NIS Request to Applicant (pdf 332Kb)  AP3-16/2020 - NIS Report (pdf 3,037Kb) 
17 August 2023 BIM AP3-16/2020 - Information Letter to BIM (pdf 425Kb)   
12 February 2024 NPWS AP3-16/2020 - S46 request to NPWS (pdf 35,361Kb)  AP3-16/2020 - S46 response from NPWS (pdf 206Kb) 
07 March 2024 DAFM AP3-16/2020 - S46 request to the Minister (pdf 173Kb)   

 

Technical Reports

Date  Type View Document
22 March 2024 Appropriate Assessment Supplemental Report AP3-16/2020 - AA Supplementary Report (pdf 367Kb) 
05 April 2024 Appropriate Assessment Conclusion Statement AP3-16/2020 - AA Conclusion Statement (pdf 133Kb) 
10 April 2024 Technical Advisor's Report AP3-16/2020 - Technical Advisor's Report (pdf 2,564Kb) 

 

Determination

Date Document Type View Document
22 May 2024 Determination AP16/1-2/2020 - Determination (pdf 171Kb) 
23 May 2024 Notification of Determination AP16/1-2/2020 - Notification of Determination (pdf 521Kb) 
30 May 2024 Newspaper Notice AP3-16/2020 - Newspaper Advert Donegal Democrat (pdf 500Kb) 
07 June 2024 Notification of Determination AP3-16/2020 - Notification of Determinations - Observers (pdf 975Kb)