By using this website, you consent to our use of cookies. For more information on cookies see our Privacy Policy Page
| Appeal Ref | Appellant | Site Ref | Subject matter of appeal | Applicant | Licence | Type | Determination Date | Minister's Decision | Status of Appeal | Oral Hearing Requested |
| AP5/2020 | Save Ballyness Bay | T12/409B | Appeal against the decision by the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine to grant a variation Aquaculture Licence to Edward and Paul O’Brien for authorisation to cultivate clams on wooden trays under mesh and Pacific Oysters using bags and trestles & Clams on wooden trays under mesh on the inter‐tidal/sub‐tidal foreshore on site ref T12/409B in Ballyness Bay, Co. Donegal | Edward & Paul O’Brien | New License | Clams & Pacific Oysters | 22 May 2024 | Grant with variation | Stage 5: Determination Made | Yes |
| Date | Appeal Ref | View Document |
| 02 January 2020 | AP5/2020 | AP5/2020 - Redacted Appeal (pdf 29,595Kb) |
| Date | Document Type | View Document |
| 09 January 2020 | Acknowledgement of Appeal | AP5/2020 - Acknowledgement of Appeal (pdf 918Kb) |
| 04 February 2020 | Notification of Appeal | AP5/2020 - Notification of Appeal (pdf 1,004Kb) |
Time Extension Letters |
||
| Received 02 January 2020 | 01 May 2020 (Original) | N/A |
| 24 March 2020 | 31 December 2020 | AP5/2020 - 2020 March Time Extensions (pdf 852Kb) |
| 10 November 2020 | 30 June 2021 | AP5/2020 - 2020 November Time Extensions (pdf 783Kb) |
| 09 June 2021 | 31 December 2021 | AP5/2020 - 2021 June Time Extensions (pdf 782Kb) |
| 29 November 2021 | 30 June 2022 | AP5/2020 - 2021 November Time Extensions (pdf 168Kb) |
| 16 May 2022 | 31 December 2022 | AP5/2020 - 2022 May Time Extensions (pdf 288Kb) |
| 20 December 2022 | 30 September 2023 | AP5/2020 - 2022 December Time Extensions (pdf 156Kb) |
| 10 August 2023 | 30 April 2024 |
AP5/2020 - 2023 August Time Extensions (pdf 2,075Kb) AP3-16/2020 - Time Extension & Cover Note to Observers (pdf 2,142Kb) |
| 17 April 2024 | 31 May 2024 |
AP5/2020 - 2024 April Time Extensions (pdf 144Kb) AP3-16/2020 - 2024 April Time Extensions (Observers) (pdf 141Kb) |
| Consolidation Letters & Information Notes | ||
| 29 November 2020 | Consolidation of Appeals | AP3-16/2020 - Consolidation of Appeals (pdf 887Kb) |
| 06 December 2023 | Information Letter | AP3-16/2020 - Information Letter to All Parties (pdf 1,702Kb) |
| Date of Request | Date of Receipt | View Document |
| 09 January 2020 | 23 January 2020 | AP5-2020 - Consolidated DAFM File (pdf 15,031Kb) |
| 09 January 2020 | 23 January 2020 | Appropriate Assessment Ballyness Bay Report (pdf 2,298Kb) |
| 09 January 2020 | 23 January 2020 | Ballyness Bay Final AA Conclusion Statement (pdf 1,038Kb) |
| Date of Receipt | From | View Document |
| 11 March 2020 | Donegal County Council | AP3-16/2020 - Observations from Donegal C.C (pdf 309Kb) |
| 12 March 2020 | An Taisce | AP3-16/2020 - Observations from An Taisce (pdf 172Kb) |
| 12 March 2020 | Save Ballyness Bay | AP3-16/2020 - Observations from Madden & Finucane Solicitors (pdf 8,500Kb) |
| 20 February 2020 | Joseph Coll | AP5/2020 - Observations from Licensee (pdf 2,385Kb) |
| Date | Recipient | View Request | View Submission |
| 24 March 2023 | Marine Institute | AP3-16-2020 - S47 Request to Marine Institute (pdf 916Kb) | AP3-16/2020 - S47 Reply from Marine Institute (pdf 54Kb) |
| 01 August 2023 | Marine Institute | AP3-16/2020 - S47 Follow up letter to MI (pdf 42Kb) | |
| 01 August 2023 | NPWS | AP3-16/2020 - S46 Request to NPWS (pdf 1,596Kb) |
AP3-16/2020 - NPWS Response to S46 (pdf 70Kb) AP3-16/2020 - ALAB response to NPWS S46 (pdf 155Kb) |
| 04 August 2023 | Applicant | AP5/2020 - NIS Request to Applicant (pdf 198Kb) | AP3-16/2020 - NIS Report (pdf 3,037Kb) |
| 17 August 2023 | BIM | AP3-16/2020 - Information Letter to BIM (pdf 425Kb) | |
| 12 February 2024 | NPWS | AP3-16/2020 - S46 request to NPWS (pdf 35,361Kb) | AP3-16/2020 - S46 response from NPWS (pdf 206Kb) |
| 07 March 2024 | DAFM | AP3-16/2020 - S46 request to the Minister (pdf 173Kb) |
| Date | Type | View Document |
| 22 March 2024 | Appropriate Assessment Supplemental Report | AP3-16/2020 - AA Supplementary Report (pdf 367Kb) |
| 05 April 2024 | Appropriate Assessment Conclusion Statement | AP3-16/2020 - AA Conclusion Statement (pdf 133Kb) |
| 10 April 2024 | Technical Advisor's Report | AP3-16/2020 - Technical Advisor's Report (pdf 2,564Kb) |
| 30 April 2024 | Seal Haul Out Site Report | Altemar report - Seal haul out site (pdf 2,154Kb) |
| 10 May 2024 | Route Access Map | AP5/2020 - Route Access Map (pdf 181Kb) |
| Date | Document Type | View Document |
| 22 May 2024 | Determination | AP5/2020 - Determination (pdf 274Kb) |
| 23 May 2024 | Notification of Determination | AP5/2020 - Notification of Determination (pdf 202Kb) |
| 30 May 2024 | Newspaper Notice | AP3-16/2020 - Newspaper Advert Donegal Democrat (pdf 500Kb) |
| 07 June 2024 | Notification of Determination | AP3-16/2020 - Notification of Determinations - Observers (pdf 975Kb) |